The Ness fishing boat Kilda, lost on 13 October with three men aboard, has been recovered semi-submerged off Orkney and taken to Kirkwall, where investigators will now examine her.
There are stories in this trade that we would much rather not have to write, and the long, sad search for the Kilda is one of them. The 8 metre fishing boat, registered PD 565, was last known to be working close to the Port of Ness at the northern tip of the Isle of Lewis on Tuesday 13 October when she failed to come home. Three men were aboard. The body of Douglas Craigie was recovered in the area at about 2.45am the following morning, according to Police Scotland, and his crewmates Norman Murray, known as Tam, who is 40, and Murdo Morrison, who is 23, remain unaccounted for and are still being treated by police as missing people.
What followed was the sort of patient, unglamorous multi-agency effort that rarely makes national headlines but which every coastal community knows well: coastguard aircraft, lifeboat crews, police marine units, volunteers and, later, the Northern Lighthouse Board vessel NLV Pharos, which surveyed the seabed east of the Butt of Lewis and identified two sites of interest. Police Scotland said those sites were examined with specialist equipment provided by the salmon farmer MOWI, working with the Marine Accident Investigation Branch, and that nothing relating to the Kilda was found, after which the maritime exclusion zone was lifted. On 5 November the boat's empty life raft turned up at West Burrafirth in Shetland, roughly 200 miles from where she had gone missing, which told the searchers something about the drift and very little about the men.
Then, at about 10.30 on Wednesday morning, HM Coastguard received a report of a partially sunken vessel in the North Sea east of Orkney, roughly 50 miles out according to the BBC, spotted by another fishing boat whose crew could not safely get aboard. A coastguard aircraft flew over and confirmed, in the Maritime and Coastguard Agency's careful phrase, that no further search and rescue activity was required; the coastguard's counter-pollution team began monitoring and a security broadcast went out warning vessels to keep clear. On Thursday evening the wreck was lifted from the water and brought into Kirkwall, and Police Scotland has confirmed that she is the Kilda.
Inspector Neil Taylor of Police Scotland said: "Our thoughts remain with everyone affected by this tragic incident. The vessel recovered has been confirmed as the FV Kilda and we will continue to work with partners, including the MAIB, Maritime and Coastguard Agency, as well as local maritime experts, as our enquiries continue." He asked for patience while what he called "a complex operation" is carried out, and thanked the Orkney marine contractors Northerly Marine and Leask Marine for bringing the boat in. The families have asked, again, for their privacy to be respected, and we will respect it here.
For the investigators, having the boat itself changes everything. The MAIB's published list of current investigations records the case as the loss of a UK-registered 8m fishing vessel off Port of Ness resulting in one fatality and two missing crew, still at the preliminary assessment stage, which is the point at which the branch decides how far and how formally to go. A hull, its fittings, its hatches, its gear and its life-saving equipment can answer questions that a liferaft on a Shetland beach never could, and the branch said on Wednesday that it was gathering information to decide its next steps. It is worth saying plainly that nobody, the MAIB included, has yet said what happened to the Kilda, and nor will we guess.
It is also worth remembering how crowded that MAIB list is with small fishing boats this year. Alongside the Kilda it includes the grounding of the fishing vessel Genesis off Hoy on 1 October, the foundering of the 7.5m James & Josephine in Carlingford Lough in June, with one life lost, and a fatal man overboard from the 5.75m Doris off West Bay in Dorset in August. Small boats, small crews, cold water and a long way from help: the pattern is old, and so is the grief.