A tanker with its rudder jammed hard to starboard struck the docked paddle-wheeler American Heritage in New Orleans on 13 November, capsizing her in 22 minutes, yet all 190 people aboard survived.

Anyone who has brought a small boat up Southampton Water while a container ship looms astern, or nosed along the Thames while a tug and barge come round the bend, knows the quiet arithmetic of sharing a channel with something many times your size, which is why the footage from New Orleans last Friday has been watched so widely on both sides of the Atlantic. American Cruise Lines’ American Heritage, an 81-metre paddle-wheeler built in 2015 for up to 150 passengers, had tied up beside the Port of New Orleans offices a couple of hours earlier at the end of an eight-day Mississippi cruise, and passengers were preparing to go ashore when the 160-metre, Marshall Islands-flagged asphalt tanker Atlantic Asphalt swung across the river and drove into her side shortly before half past twelve local time.

The National Transportation Safety Board, which is leading the investigation with the US Coast Guard, has given a preliminary account drawn from more than nine hours of voyage data recorder information. The tanker, with a crew of 19 and a local pilot aboard, had left an anchorage downriver that morning bound upstream for an oil terminal at Reserve, Louisiana, and as she passed close to the Crescent City Connection bridge her steering failed with the rudder left to starboard, sending her towards the east bank, where she struck the riverboat about two minutes later. The recorder captured what investigators described as sounds consistent with the ship’s whistle, warnings and calls for help on the radio, orders to let go the anchors and emergency manoeuvres, and senior investigator Bart Barnum was careful to say that the cause of the failure itself is still unknown and “could be many different things”.

What happened next is the reason the city’s mayor, Helena Moreno, called it a “miracle on the Mississippi”. The NTSB says there were 140 passengers and 50 crew aboard the American Heritage, and New Orleans harbour police say 87 of them got off before she rolled onto her side, after which tugs, towboats, the port fireboat, the Coast Guard, police and fire crews pulled the rest from the river in around 30 to 45 minutes. Thirty-two people, including two harbour police officers who were thrown into the water, went to hospital, none with critical injuries, and American Cruise Lines has singled out Captain Leonard Stewart, who it says stayed on the bridge as the boat went over, calling for help and holding her alongside the quay for as long as he could.

Maritime news site gCaptain has pointed to the crews of commercial tugs and towboats who turned towards the trouble within minutes, and it is hard to read the account without thinking of the RNLI crews, harbour launches and workboat skippers who would be first on scene in a British port. The river was closed to traffic between mile markers 93 and 96 while the rescue went on, the Port of New Orleans filed a federal lawsuit within hours claiming at least $1 million of damage to its terminal, a judge placed the tanker under federal control, and salvage of the half-submerged riverboat is expected to take weeks. The NTSB says a preliminary report should follow within 30 days, and it has stressed that it will look at what went right as well as what went wrong.

The wider question is one every busy harbour faces, because the Lower Mississippi, like the Solent, the Thames and the Mersey, puts deep-draught ocean ships within a few boat lengths of passenger vessels, workboats and leisure craft, and the margin for a mechanical failure is measured in minutes. In Britain, oversight of that system is itself under the spotlight, after The Herald reported last week that the Maritime and Coastguard Agency had wrongly told a requester it held no record of any inspections, audits or other regulatory checks on the ferry operator CalMac between January 2020 and January 2025, a statement an MCA source later admitted was wrong. The request followed the grounding of the 1986-built ferry Loch Linnhe in the Sound of Gigha in January 2025, when CalMac says she was sailing without the legally required passage plan, and CalMac insists the MCA carried out regular audits and inspections of its ships throughout that period.

None of that suggests a New Orleans-style accident is waiting to happen in British waters, but both stories make the same point from different directions, which is that passenger safety depends on machinery that works, crews who are drilled to act in seconds and regulators who can show their working. For those of us in small boats, the practical lessons are as old as seamanship itself: keep well clear of big ships in narrow channels, listen to port VTS on the VHF and remember that a ship which suddenly sounds five or more short blasts is telling you it does not understand your intentions,. It costs nothing to give way early.